NT Farmers thanks Acting Chief Minister Gerard Maley for his strong support for growers and the Country Liberal Party’s call for a Territory exemption to the proposed working holiday maker visa changes.
While an exemption would be a positive step for the Territory, NT Farmers also calls for a nationwide pause on the proposed caps and ballot system for at least 12 months so adequate consultation with industry can occur, and the true impacts can be properly assessed by the Federal Government.
Currently, there is insufficient evidence provided to support the decision, no acceptable management plan for a significant workforce transition, and serious doubt that the economic impacts on growers have been properly considered.
There is no doubt however that proposed caps and the new ballot system will reduce the number of working holiday makers able to extend their stay and will weaken the incentive to undertake the regional work which Territory growers rely on to pick, pack and get their produce to market. In the current climate, while the industry manages the ongoing impacts of the Middle East conflict following a season with multiple cyclones and significant flood events, another shock for growers is ill-timed and simply unacceptable.
Backpackers are an integral part of the agricultural workforce. Many businesses require a large surge workforce for a short period of time, measured in weeks rather than months. These short harvest windows cannot, on their own, provide year-round employment and are therefore not suitable jobs to attract a sustainable local workforce. Backpackers help growers meet this concentrated demand with a ready, willing and able workforce.
In exchange for backpackers doing the tough work in regional communities and supporting our agricultural industry, the Australian Government currently provides a reliable pathway to extend their time in Australia. The proposed changes fundamentally change that arrangement. While the ballot system still requires eligible regional work to enable entry, it substantially weakens the incentive to complete that work. This impact alone is significant, before we even get to the 38,000 fewer second- and third-year visa places under the proposed caps compared with the previous year’s figures cited by the Minister.
It is easy to understand why working holiday makers would choose to work in Sydney, Melbourne or Brisbane over completing regional work in agriculture without certainty of extending their stay. As the proposed caps are well below the previous year’s figures, many who completed the work could miss out, and the prospect of that outcome may lead some to opt out of regional work entirely.
NT Farmers applauds the National Farmers’ Federation’s immediate advocacy on this issue and congratulates them on establishing a priority processing arrangement for critical applications. However, most of the concerns remain unresolved for Territory growers. Many of the working holiday makers our growers rely on do not come to Australia with agricultural experience for a specific job but complete the work as part of their travels.
Priority processing can help with urgent applications, but it does not address the core problem.
Suggestions that the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) scheme can replace any lost backpackers do not acknowledge the different roles the two workforce solutions provide. PALM workers are an important part of our industry. Many growers use both PALM workers and backpackers to ensure they can meet their seasonal requirements, but one cannot simply replace the other. The suggestion that agricultural businesses can simply utilise
PALM to replace backpackers shows a lack of understanding of the on-ground realities and nuance involved in managing surge workforce requirements.
Accessing the PALM scheme, whether directly as an approved employer or through an approved labour-hire provider, involves advance planning, employment commitments, costs and administrative requirements that are not suitable for every farm or every short- term labour need. Backpackers provide flexibility to respond to changing demands at short notice during intense harvest windows. To operate their businesses effectively, many growers need access to both.
NT Farmers’ position is very straightforward. The seasonal workforce the Territory relies on needs to be protected, and an exemption would be an important step in securing that protection. We also call for a nationwide pause of at least 12 months on the proposed caps and ballot so the Government can adequately work through the impacts with industry and provide meaningful solutions before implementation. NT Farmers will continue to advocate for our growers to ensure the realities on Territory farms are heard in the national debate.